The Evangelization Station
Pray for Pope Francis
Scroll down for topics
SEVEN YEARS OF ASSISTED SUICIDE IN OREGON
Under Oregons law permitting physician-assisted suicide, the Oregon Department of Human Services (DHS) previously called the Oregon Health Division (OHD) is required to collect information, review a sample of cases and publish a yearly statistical report. (1) Since the law, called the "Death with Dignity Act," went into effect in 1997, seven official reports have been published. However, due to major flaws in the law and the state's reporting system, there is no way to know for sure how many or under what circumstances patients have died from physician-assisted suicide.
ASSISTED SUICIDE DEATHS REPORTED DURING FIRST SEVEN YEARS
Official Reports: 208
The latest annual report indicates that reported assisted-suicide deaths have increased by more than 225% since the first year of legal assisted suicide in Oregon. (2) The number of deaths, however, could be far greater. From the time the law went into effect, Oregon officials in charge of formulating annual reports have conceded “there’s no way to know if additional deaths went unreported” because Oregon DHS “has no regulatory authority or resources to ensure compliance with the law.” (3)
The DHS has to rely on the word of doctors who prescribe the lethal drugs. (4) Referring to physicians' reports, the reporting division admitted: "For that matter the entire account [received from doctors] could have been a cock-and bull story. We assume, however, that physicians were their usual careful and accurate selves." (5)
The Death with Dignity law contains no penalties for doctors who do
not report prescribing lethal doses for the purpose of suicide.
COMPLICATIONS OCCURRING DURING ASSISTED SUICIDE
Official Reports: 10 (instances of vomiting)
Prescribing doctors may not know about all complications since, during the seventh year, physicians who prescribe the lethal drugs for assisted suicide were present at fewer than 16% of reported deaths.(6) Information they provide might come from secondhand accounts of those present at the death (7) or may be conjecture.
Complications found in news reports are not included in official reports:
Overdoses of barbiturates are known to cause vomiting as a person begins to lose consciousness. The patient then inhales the vomit. In other cases, panic, feelings of terror and assaultive behavior can occur from the drug-induced confusion. (10) But Barrett wouldnt say exactly which symptoms had taken place in this instance. She has refused to discuss the case since her December 1999 revelation.
In the Netherlands, assisted-suicide complications and problems are not uncommon. One Dutch study found that, because of problems or complications, doctors in the Netherlands felt compelled to intervene (by giving a lethal injection) in 18% of cases. (13) This led Dr. Sherwin Nuland of Yale University of Medicine to question the credibility of Oregon's lack of reported complications. Nuland, who favors physician-assisted suicide, noted that the Dutch have had years of practice to learn ways to overcome complications, yet complications are still reported. "The Dutch findings seem more credible [than the Oregon reports]," he wrote. (14)
ASSISTED SUICIDE DEATHS OF PATIENTS WITH DEMENTIA
Official Reports: 0
Kate Cheney, 85, died of assisted suicide under Oregons law even though she reportedly was suffering from early dementia. Her own physician declined to provide the lethal prescription. When counseling to determine her capacity was sought, a psychiatrist determined that she was not eligible for assisted suicide since she was not explicitly seeking it, and her daughter seemed to be coaching her to do so. She was then taken to a psychologist who determined that she was competent but possibly under the influence of her daughter who was "somewhat coercive." Finally, the managed care ethicist, who was overseeing her case, determined that she was qualified for assisted suicide, and the drugs were prescribed. (15)
ASSISTED SUICIDE DEATHS OF DEPRESSED PATIENTS
Official Reports: 0
During the last year for which reports are available, only 5% of patients were referred for a psychological evaluation or counseling before receiving a prescription for assisted suicide. (19) Under the assisted-suicide law, depressed or mentally ill patients can receive assisted suicide if they do not have "impaired judgment." (20) Concerning the decision to refer for a psychological evaluation, Oregon epidemiologist Dr. Mel Kohn said, "According to the law, it's up to the docs' discretion." (21)
ASSISTED SUICIDE REQUESTS BASED ON FINANCIAL CONCERNS
Actual number: Unknown
Data about reasons for requests is based on prescribing doctors' understanding of patients' motivations. It is possible that financial concerns were much greater than reported. According to official reports, 36% of patients whose deaths were reported were on Medicare (for senior citizens) or Medicaid (for the poor). (22) However, after the second annual report, the reports have not differentiated between Medicare and Medicaid patients dying from assisted suicide. Oregon's Medicaid program pays for assisted suicide (23) but not for many other medical interventions that patients need and want.
PATIENTS WHO RECEIVED LETHAL DOSE MORE THAN 6 MONTHS BEFORE DEATH
Official Reports: 2 or 4 (After 2nd year, official
reports deleted category)
Lethal prescriptions under the "Death with Dignity Act" are supposed to be limited to patients who have a life expectancy of six months or less. (24) However, one patient was still alive 17 months after the lethal drugs were prescribed. (25)
During the first two years of the law's implementation, at least one lethal dose was prescribed more than 8 months before the patient took it. (26) The sixth annual report noted that 2 patients who received prescriptions in 2002 and another who received the prescription in 2001 died from the lethal drugs in 2003. (27)
The DHS is not authorized to investigate how physicians determine their patients diagnoses or life expectancies.(29) If physicians are prescribing for patients who do not have a terminal condition, there is no way to find out since the same doctors who are violating the guidelines would have to report their own violations. "[N]oncompliance is difficult to assess because of the possible repercussions for noncompliant physicians reporting data to the division." (30)
SHORTEST LENGTH OF TIME REPORTED FOR PRESCRIBING DOCTOR/PATIENT RELATIONSHIP
Official Reports: Less than 1 week
Although Oregon's assisted-suicide law requires that at least 2 weeks must elapse between the patient's first and last requests for lethal drugs,(31) the physician who actually prescribes the drugs for assisted suicide need not be the same physician to whom the first request was made.
For the 3rd through the 6th years, the doctor-patient relationship in some assisted suicide cases was under one week.(32) Thus, either some physicians are not complying with the 2 week requirement or they stepped in to write an assisted-suicide prescription after other physician(s) refused.
FIRST PHYSICIAN ASKED AGREED TO WRITE PRESCRIPTION
Official Reports: 27 (41%) (After 3rd year, official
reports deleted category)
"Many patients who sought assistance with suicide had to ask more than one physician for a prescription for lethal medication." (33) Patients or their families can "doctor shop" until a willing physician is found. There is no way to know, however, why the previous physicians refused to lethally prescribe (i.e. the patient was not terminally ill, had impaired judgment, etc.), since non-prescribing physicians are not interviewed for the official state reports. The only physicians interviewed for official reports are those who actually wrote lethal drug prescriptions for patients. (34)
The unwillingness of many physicians to write lethal prescriptions led one HMO to issue a plea for physicians to facilitate assisted suicide and has also resulted in an assisted-suicide advocacy organization's involvement in most assisted-suicide cases.
Family members do not need to be informed before a doctor helps a loved one commit suicide.
Family notification is only recommended, but not require, under
Oregon's assisted-suicide law.(40) The first time that a family
learns that a loved one was considering suicide could be after the
death has occurred.
Oregon's law provides greater protection for doctors than for patients.
While assisted-suicide advocates claim that patients are given new rights under Oregon's law, nothing could be farther from the truth. Prior to the law's passage, patients could request, but doctors could not provide, assisted suicide. It was illegal and unethical for a physician to knowingly participate in a patient's suicide. The law actually empowers doctors by promising them legal immunity if they provide a patient with an intentionally fatal prescription. Yet, advocates still say that the law grants patients a new legal right - the right to ask their doctors for suicide assistance, even though such a request was never illegal. Suicide requests from patients may have been cries for better pain control, support, or psychiatric help - but they were never a crime.
In addition, doctors who prescribe assisted suicide under Oregon's law are exempt from the standard of care that they are required to meet when providing other medical services. Under the assisted-suicide law, a health care provider is not subject to criminal or civil liability or any other professional disciplinary action as long as the provider is acting in "good faith." (41) This subjective "good faith" standard is far less stringent than the objective "reasonable standard of care" which physicians are required to meet for compassionate medical care such as hospice, palliation or curative treatment.
As a result, a doctor who negligently "participates" (42) in assisted suicide cannot be held accountable so long as he or she claims to have acted in "good faith." On the other hand, a doctor who negligently provides other medical interventions can be held legally accountable in civil court regardless of his or her "good faith."
This lowering of the standard of care for assisted suicide could serve as an inducement for doctors to recommend assisted suicide over palliative care at the end of life.
In the coming months, other states will be considering Oregon-type laws. It remains to be seen whether decision-makers will rely on the deceptively rosy picture painted by assisted-suicide supporters, or on its reality.
(1) ORS 127.865 §3.11.
(2) DHS, "Seventh Annual Report on Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act," March 10, 2005. (http://egov.oregon.gov/DHS/ph/pas/docs/year7.pdf)
(3) Linda Prager, "Details emerge on Oregon’s first assisted suicides, " American Medical News, September 7, 1998.
(4) Joe Rojas-Burke, "Suicide critics say lack of problems in Oregon is odd," Oregonian, February 24, 2000.
(5) Oregon Health Division, CD Summary, vol. 48, no. 6 (March 16, 1999), p. 2. (http://www.ohd.hr.state.or.us/chs/pas/pascdsm2.htm)
(6) Supra note 2, p. 14.
(7) DHS, "Fifth Annual Report on Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act," March 6, 2003, p. 9. (http://www.ohd.hr.state.or.us/chs/pas/year5/ar-index.cfm)
(8) Erin Hoover, "Dilemma of assisted suicide: When?" Oregonian, January 17,1999 and Erin Hoover, "Man with ALS makes up his mind to die," Oregonian, March 11, 1999.
(9) Audio tape on file with author. Also see Catherine Hamilton, "The Oregon Report: What’s Hiding behind the Numbers?" Brainstorm, March 2000 (http://www.brainstormnw.com); David Reinhard, "The pills don’t kill: The case, First of two parts," Oregonian, March 23, 2000 and David Reinhard, "The pills don’t kill: The cover-up, Second of two parts," Oregonian, March 26, 2000.
(10) Johanna H. Groenewoud et al, "Clinical Problems with the Performance of Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide in the Netherlands," 342 New England Journal of Medicine (February 24, 2000), pp. 553-555.
(11) Associated Press, "Assisted suicide attempt fails," March 4, 2005.
(12) DHS news release, "No authority to investigate Death with Dignity case, DHS says," March 4, 2005.
(13) Supra note 10.
(14) Sherwin Nuland, "Physician-Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia in Practice," 342 New England Journal of Medicine (February 24, 2000), pp. 583-584.
(15) Erin Barnett, "A family struggle: Is Mom capable of choosing to die?" Oregonian, October 17, 1999.
(16) Dr. Peter Goodwin was an Associate Professor (now professor emeritus) in the Department of Family Medicine at the Oregon Health Sciences University in Portland, Oregon and was Chair of Oregon Right to Die during the campaign to pass Oregon’s assisted-suicide law. He had been active in the Hemlock Society. Speaking at a 1993 Hemlock conference in Orlando, Florida, he explained that he favored both the lethal injection and assisted suicide, but he realized that most people were not yet ready to accept the former so incremental steps would need to be taken.
(17) Erin Hoover and Gail Hill, "Two die using suicide law; Woman on tape says she looks forward to relief," Oregonian, March 26, 1998; Kim Murphy, "Death Called 1st under Oregon’s New Suicide Law," Los Angeles Times, March 26, 1998; and Diane Gianelli, "Praise, criticism follow Oregon’s first reported assisted suicides," American Medical News, April 13, 1998.
(18) N. Gregory Hamilton, M.D. and Catherine Hamilton, M.A., "Competing Paradigms of Responding to Assisted-Suicide Requests in Oregon: Case Report," presented at the American Psychiatric Association Annual Meeting, New York, New York, May 6, 2004. (http://www.pccef.oorg/articles/art28.htm)
(19) Supra note 2, pg. 13.
(20) ORS 127.825 §3.03.
(21) Andis Robenznieks, "Assisted-suicide numbers in Oregon," American Medical News, April 5, 2004.
(22) Supra note 2, p. 24, Table 4.
(23) Erin Hoover Barnett, "Suicide coverage passes review," Oregonian, April 26, 1999.
(24) ORS 127.800 §12; ORS 127.815 §a.
(25) Supra note 18.
(26) Department of Human Services (DHS), Oregon Health Division (OHD), "Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act: The Second Year’s Experience," February 23, 2000, Table 2. (http://www.ohd.hr.state.or.us/chs/pas /year2/ar-index.cfm)
(27) DHS, "Sixth Annual Report on Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act," March 10, 2004, p. 11. (http://www.ohd.hr.state.or.us/chs/pas /ar-index.cfm)
(28) Supra note 2, p. 12.
(29) Katrina Hedberg et al, Letter to the Editor in response to "The Oregon Report: Neutrality at OHD?," Hastings Center Report, January-February 2000, p. 4.
(30) Amy Sullivan, Katrina Hedberg, David Fleming, "Legalized Physician-Assisted Suicide in Oregon – The Second Year," 342 New England Journal of Medicine (February 24, 2000), p. 603.
(31) ORS 127.840 §3.08.
(32) Supra note 2, p. 25.
(33) Supra note 30.
(34) Supra note 2, p. 10.
(35) Andis Robeznieks, "HMO query reignites assisted-suicide controversy," American Medical News, September 9, 2002.
(38) Transcript of tape of Peter Goodwin, "Oregon," January 11, 2003, presented at 13th National Hemlock Biennial Conference, "Charting a New Course, Building on a Solid Foundation, Imagining a Brighter Future for America’s Terminally Ill," January 9-12, 2003, Bahia Resort Hotel, San Diego California.
(39) "Compassion in Dying of Oregon Summary of Hastened Deaths," Data attached to Compassion in Dying of Oregon’s IRS Form 990 for 2003.
(40) ORS 127.835, §3.05.
(41) ORS 127.885, §4.01 (1).
(42) "Participate" means to perform the duties of an attending physician, consulting physician, or counseling function described in the law ORS 127.885, §4.01(5)(D)(b).